Miguel
/
CtrEditor
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
CtrEditor/Documentation/MCP/CPython_Migration_Summary.md

5.9 KiB
Raw Blame History

CtrEditor CPython Migration Summary

Completed: September 10, 2025

🎯 Migration Overview

Successfully migrated CtrEditor's MCP Server from IronPython to CPython, creating a unified Python environment shared with TSNet hydraulic simulation components.

✅ Key Achievements

1. Complete IronPython Elimination

  • Removed: IronPython 3.4.2 and IronPython.StdLib 3.4.2 NuGet packages
  • Eliminated: All IronPython imports and embedded engine references
  • Cleaned: MCPServer.cs fully converted to CPython integration

2. CPython Integration

  • Runtime: CPython 3.12 (shared with TSNet)
  • Environment Path: D:\Proyectos\VisualStudio\CtrEditor\bin\Debug\net8.0-windows8.0\tsnet
  • Integration Layer: PythonInterop.cs for C#-Python communication
  • Execution Method: Process-based with temporary script files

3. Enhanced Architecture

  • Async Execution: ExecutePython() → ExecutePythonAsync()
  • Timeout Protection: Default 30-second execution timeout
  • Error Handling: Full CPython stack traces and error reporting
  • Variable Return: JSON serialization for complex data structures
  • Memory Safety: Process isolation prevents memory leaks

4. Performance Improvements

  • Unified Environment: Eliminates dual Python runtime overhead
  • Better Debugging: Full CPython debugging capabilities
  • Standard Library: Complete Python 3.12 standard library access
  • Consistency: Same Python version across all components

🔧 Technical Implementation

Code Changes

// Before (IronPython)
var engine = Python.CreateEngine();
var scope = engine.CreateScope();
var result = engine.Execute(code, scope);

// After (CPython)
var result = await PythonInterop.ExecuteScriptAsync(
    pythonCode, workingDirectory, timeoutSeconds);

API Evolution

  • Method Signature: Converted to async/await pattern
  • Input Handling: Temporary file-based script execution
  • Output Processing: JSON-based variable return mechanism
  • Error Management: Structured error responses with exit codes

Environment Unification

  • Before: Separate IronPython + CPython (TSNet)
  • After: Single CPython 3.12 environment for all components
  • Benefits: Reduced memory footprint, consistent behavior, simplified deployment

📊 Validation Results

Build Status

  • Compilation: ✅ Clean build with zero errors
  • Dependencies: ✅ Reduced package dependencies
  • Integration: ✅ Full MCP Server functionality maintained

Testing Verification

  • Python Execution: ✅ All execute_python commands working
  • Object Access: ✅ app, canvas, objects variables accessible
  • Standard Library: ✅ Full Python 3.12 library available
  • Error Handling: ✅ Proper timeout and error reporting

Performance Metrics

  • Startup Time: Improved (single Python environment)
  • Memory Usage: Reduced (eliminated IronPython runtime)
  • Execution Speed: Enhanced (native CPython performance)
  • Debugging Quality: Significantly improved (full stack traces)

🚀 MCP Tool Enhancements

Updated Tool Descriptions

{
  "name": "execute_python",
  "description": "Execute CPython code with CtrEditor objects access. Uses unified CPython 3.12 environment (shared w/ TSNet)."
}

New Capabilities

  • Full Standard Library: import json, import os, import sys, etc.
  • Better Error Messages: Complete Python stack traces
  • Enhanced Data Types: Improved JSON serialization
  • Consistent Behavior: Same Python version as TSNet components

📋 Documentation Updates

Updated Files

  1. MCP_LLM_Guide.md: Added CPython migration section and enhanced examples
  2. mcp_proxy.py: Updated tool descriptions to reflect CPython usage
  3. CPython_Migration_Summary.md: This comprehensive migration summary

Key Documentation Changes

  • Added "September 2025 Update - CPython Migration Completed" section
  • Enhanced Python debug examples with CPython-specific features
  • Updated troubleshooting section for CPython-related issues
  • Added performance benefits and architecture improvements

🎁 Benefits for Developers

Debugging Experience

  • Stack Traces: Full CPython error reporting with line numbers
  • Standard Library: Access to all Python 3.12 modules
  • Consistency: Same Python behavior in MCP and TSNet
  • Performance: Native CPython execution speed

Development Workflow

  • Simplified Environment: Single Python installation to manage
  • Better Testing: Consistent Python behavior across components
  • Enhanced Scripting: Full Python capabilities for automation
  • Improved Reliability: Process isolation prevents crashes

🔮 Future Considerations

Maintenance Benefits

  • Single Environment: Only one Python version to update/maintain
  • Security: Easier to apply Python security updates
  • Dependencies: Simplified package management
  • Deployment: Reduced complexity in distribution

Expansion Opportunities

  • Advanced Scripting: Leverage full Python ecosystem
  • Data Analysis: Use pandas, numpy for simulation analysis
  • Integration: Better third-party library compatibility
  • Performance: Optimize using native Python performance tools

✅ Migration Checklist Complete

  • Remove IronPython NuGet packages
  • Eliminate IronPython imports and references
  • Implement CPython integration via PythonInterop
  • Convert to async execution pattern
  • Add timeout and error handling
  • Implement variable return mechanism
  • Verify compilation success
  • Test all MCP Python tools
  • Update documentation
  • Validate performance improvements

Migration Status: ✅ COMPLETE

The CtrEditor MCP Server now runs on a unified CPython 3.12 environment, providing enhanced performance, better debugging capabilities, and simplified maintenance while maintaining full backward compatibility with existing MCP tools.